CULTURAL BRIDGE PRODUCTIONS
Kota Bharu, Malaysia

[November, 1995] Something of the identity of Kota Bharu, the capital of the peninsular Malaysian state of Kelantan, can be gleaned from flipping through the phone directory. In just over seven hundred pages of names listed in the directory, nearly ten percent begin with the name Mohammed and another five percent begin with the name Abdullah. Where this pattern is contradicted most noticeably it is with names like Chen, Low, Lok, and Wong which are also heavily represented in the book. Kelantan is the only state in Malaysia not run by the ruling party. Instead it is run by an opposition party which has assured that Kelantan is the most noticeably Islamic state in Malaysia. According to some it also means that Kelantan has suffered neglect from the ruling part in Kuala Lumpur who is punishing the Kelantan people for voting the opposition party into power.

Eating

In the neighboring Philippines, the ethnically related Filipino people normally eat with a spoon and fork, using the fork to push food into the spoon and eating it from the spoon. In the privacy of their own homes, Filipinos often eat with their hands in a traditional manner. In Thailand they used the same utensils, but traditionally ate with their hands as well. The Spanish and American colonial rulers put an end to eating-with-your-hands in the Philippines and King Chulalongkorn probably did away with it in Thailand during his reign of "modernization". In Malaysia, my wife, Karen (who was raised in the Philippines) was glad to learn, they not only eat with a spoon and fork, but even encourage people to eat with their hands in public. There is one rule that applies, and I'm sure always did apply in the eating-with-your-hands countries, don't eat with your left hand because that is the hand you use to wipe your butt when in the bathroom (toilet paper is not universal!).

The Thai and Malaysians

The facial characteristics of the people we saw in Kota Bharu were noticeably different from the people of the various areas of Thailand we had been to. This probably wouldn't be surprising to Malaysians or Thai people, but it was for me having been raised in an America where I can't remember having ever heard anything about Southeast Asia in my formal education from kindergarten through high school (the Vietnam War was mentioned but never discussed openly). I would be hard pressed to explain these physical differences now that I have said they exist, but suffice here to say that there is a difference. Undoubtedly the difference has been maintained by contrasting religious beliefs that inhibit intermarriage even if there are cultural similarities between the people. Both countries consider it bad to point with your feet which are unclean or to touch somebody else's head because it is the most sacrosanct part of the body. I'm sure that underlying these relatively superficial points are more profound cultural similarities perhaps even nativistic beliefs that have been covered over with more recent influences.

Kelantan Muslim Society & Women's Wear

I asked the desk clerk, a Malaysian women, at our hotel who spoke English well if Malaysians were taught English in school. She told me that people in the state of Kelantan were not generally conversant in English, and that she was from a different state where she had learned English at a convent school. She then explained, embarrassed, that she had to wear the head scarf of a Muslim woman because it was the law and that she was once fined 10 ringgit for not wearing it while at work. She explained that she was having a difficult time getting used to wearing it. Kelantan is a conservative Muslim state and has proclaimed that all Muslim women must wear the head scarves when working, though they are not legally required to outside of work. Muslim men have no similar requirement affecting their attire. I saw a policewoman without a scarf and was later informed that policewoman have to wear regulation hats so they are therefore exempt from the scarf rule. We also saw a couple of young women working in a restaurant kitchen that was partially visible to patrons, and the women were not wearing the scarves either but they were not so easily seen.

One night we went to an outdoor market which was popular for the food stands that sold a variety of inexpensive, delicious Malaysian food. When we arrived there was a man walking through the area with a loudspeaker. He seemed to be advising everyone that it was time for prayers. We followed the men who were walking to a mosque which was next to the market, and noticed that the women scattered in the other direction towards retail shops across the street. There was a tarp raised by poles which covered the prayer mats where men that could not fit inside the mosque where the were led in prayer in the warm evening air. After observing the ritual prayers we walked back towards the market, but were told we could not enter the market by a guard who apologized and said the market would open up in a few minutes after the prayers were over.

Looking around it was clear that there were differing degrees of devoutness in the attire of the women. One woman was in the full purdah, only her eyes and some of her sandaled feet were visible. She was only one of maybe a few hundred women we saw that night who was dressed so. Some of the women wore head scarves that were held together by decorative broaches underneath their chins so that no skin of the neck was visible and their arms were typically covered as well. Others, probably in a similar position to the woman at our hotel, wore the scarf loosely and didn't seem to have any other clothes on the resembled a uniform as such.

At first glance the attire of Muslim Malaysian women appears to be conservative, but this is an illusion. The scarves and the cut of the dresses are borrowings from the Middle East that have been altered in a notably Southeast Asian, or more particularly, Malaysian way. The dresses are made of sheer silk so that they can cover much of a woman's skin without being stifling in the tropical environment, and the bright floral patterns blend well with the visual surroundings. Because the fabric is silk and decorated so beautifully it appears to caress the bodies of these women in a subtle, sensuous way. We looked at the fabric for these dresses at markets in Kota Bharu where the dresses are made after the cloth is purchased, and running my hand against the fabric I could not help but wonder what a luxury it accorded the Malaysian men whose wives dressed in this fabric. The contrast with photos I have seen of other Islamic areas were the larger women are covered from head to toe with a black or other neutral toned clothe that provides only a small opening for their eyes could not be greater.

Hospital Besar Kota Bharu

Having entered Malaysia with a mild gastro-intestinal disorder which had not been aidd much by a freezing night's ride aboard an air-conditioned Thai train, and was now accompanied by a headache, I decided to visit a Malaysian hospital. I was amazed with the efficiency of my visit. Within less than an hour and a half, I had checked in, seen my doctor, had a lab test performed, seen the doctor again, had my prescription filled and was out the door. For those who have travelled to areas where white-skinned Westerners are often given preferential treatment, let me add that this was not the case here. My most critical complaint with my visit had to be directed at the bathroom which was only slightly better than the ones I had seen in China (visit China section for a more thorough explanation), but the visit with all the services provided to me cost a paltry few dollars.

Malaysian Fauna

While we were laying in bed at night, Karen suddenly let out a scream and jumped up yelling, "Ipis!", Out of the corner of my eye, I saw some black thing the size of a silver dollar fly into the air, then more clearly recognized it to be a large brown cockroach which scampered under the bed. Karen had felt something against her ear and realized what it was after she flicked it. (ipis is "cockroach" in Karen's native tongue, Pilipino).

Malaysian Sign Language

Our Malaysian language skills (or lack of) were not increased by our short visit to Kota Bharu, but we did learn the Malaysian sign language for "no." Malaysians twist their hand back and forth at the wrist as if opening a door. Karen also noticed some similarities and not-so-similarities with Pilipino: anak means "child" in both Malay and Pilipino, lima means "five" in both languages, as does itik (duck), bola (ball), payung or payong (umbrella), and tali (rope); but suso in Malay means "milk", but in Pilipino it means "breast"!

News from Malaysia

Excerpts from an article in the Malaysia's New Straits Times (November 11, 1995):

KUALA LUMPUR-Anti-social activity and delinquency among youths in the country are the indirect result of rapid industrialization and globalization, Universiti Malaya's (UM) research and development deputy director Associate Professor Dr. Yaakob Harun said today.

"According to studies conducted by UM last year, a total of 9,895 girls aged 21 years and below ran away from home. In 1993, 675 youths were admitted to reform school.

"We also found out that 89 percent of parents used negative words like bodoh [stupid], bangsat [vulgar word for "idiots"], celaka [bad luck], and kurang ajar [bad mannered] on their children."

...

"The family institution has undergone a lot of changes in its structure and organisation due to rapid development in the country.

"Families in urban areas undergo a lot of stress. The entry of women into the workforce, which was previously monopolised by men, is also a contributing factor towards the change in family structure," he said at a national seminar on Family Values Towards the Development of the Country here.

He said according to research conducted in the United States, the relationship between a husband and wife would deteriorate if the focused predominantly on their careers.

"Some couples will feel that they need more freedom and in order to free themselves from the shackles of marriage, they will commit adultery.

"This will give rise to a conflict within the family which in turn will bring about other negative elements like bohsia [women who have free sex], bohjan [men who have free, or casual sex], child abuse and homosexuality."

He said the winds from the West were blowing in this direction.

'Debu-Debu Kasih' poster censored in Kota Baru

Kota Baru-The screening of Debu-Debu Kasih is being subjected to censorship in and outside a cinema here. Its female lead depicted in a poster has been covered with a blank piece of paper.

The latest Malay romance flick, with Sham of the rock group Visa and Aida Aris in the starring roles, is currently showing at the Odeon cinema here.

The female lead, Aida, is featured embracing Sham and clad in a wet, clinging T-shirt in the movie's poster.

The censorship directive, it is believed, came from the Kota Baru Municipal Council.

It is believed that the poster has breached its conditions for approval of advertising billboards which came into force in 1993.

I had a long conversation with a Malaysian woman whose ancestors had immigrated to Malaya four or five generations earlier. She was married to a man who was similarly ethnic Chinese. She felt that relations between ethnic Chinese and Bumiputras was good (Bumiputra is a name for ethnic groups who are considered "sons of the land"- a literal translation of Bumiputra though some argue that this tends to favor ethnic Malays more than other ethnic groups). When I asked her about racial violence in the past against ethnic Chinese, she said that it was really isolated to Kuala Lumpur and not really indicative of Malaysia, and a Bumiputra woman who was listening agreed.

When asked, she said that she was Malaysian, and also said she was certainly Chinese as well. She said she didn't speak Chinese though her parents did and added that her husband and her speak in English to the children at home. I'm not sure why she said she didn't speak a particular Chinese dialect because I heard her speaking in a Chinese dialect of some kind to an ethnic Chinese visitor. I could only conclude that she meant she didn't speak Mandarin, or the official language of China also known as putong hua. Her children were being sent to a school, partially supported by the Malaysian government, where they could learn Chinese. When I asked her if they were thought about Chinese culture she responded with a "no." When I asked her why she was having them learn Chinese, she explained to me that she thought it was good not because they were ethnic Chinese, but to learn a language that was important for business. She had done business in China and felt that it was difficult, and apparently a little embarrassing, conducting business because she couldn't speak Chinese.

In contrast to a less experienced, an unmarried young Chinese shop worker I spoke with in Hong Kong, this Chinese Malaysian woman said that she believed there was no such thing as a "boss" in a marriage. She seemed to contradict this though when she said that she believed Western men marry Asian women because they are more docile than outspoken Western women. She admitted that she was outspoken herself, and when I pressed her to find out who won disagreements on issues both her and her husband felt were important she dodged the question while her employee who was observing quietly laughed. She believed that women and men were clearly different arguing that men were more decisive, physically stronger and consequently more adept at jobs requiring more physical strength. Women, she believed, were more careful with money matters, and in general more detail oriented though less decisive. In striking contrast to the Hong Kong woman's idea of who was boss in a "Chinese" marriage, she said that Chinese - without specifying Malaysian Chinese - find it quite acceptable for a man to have two wives. She made this comment after discussing the permanence of marriage and asking me about adultery in America. I said that I thought divorce in America was entirely too common and that I believed that adultery in America was far less significant than it is in East Asia. One of the countries I pointed out as an example was Japan where I said that I believed it was fairly common for salarymen to have extramarital affairs. She argued that she didn't believe temporary, "paid for" extramarital affairs such as in a Japanese scenario was as much a threat as long term extramarital affairs where a mistress would be secretly set-up in a paid for- residence, or in the Chinese Malaysian case where second wives were considered acceptable (but I'm not sure by whom!).

International Westernization of the East

When taking photos in East Asian countries, and in the Tiger Countries of South Korea and Malaysia in particular, I've noticed that the older men typically wear more traditional attire while the younger men - with a few exceptions in Malaysia - tend to wear the international dress code (Western) for teenage boys: t-shirts with American sport team names or messages in English, and athletic shoes. As they get older they wear collared shirts and sometimes dress shoes. For businessmen, the de rigeur is American-British style business suits with ties though the Philippines seems to be the last hold-out in this area where pineapple-fabric barong tagalogs are worn (and more suitable to Southeast Asian climates). The only exception to this general rule that we observed occurred in Seoul, South Korea where a couple of bridegrooms wore the traditional hanbok for their wedding pictures inside the ever popular sites for these sort of photos, old palace grounds.

Copyright CULTURAL BRIDGE PRODUCTIONS, All Rights Reserved.